Live Feed:New episodes, highlights, and rapid recaps
Episodes
•32:18 •S2E8

The Role of a Magistrate with Aneesa Noor | How to Think Like a Lawyer

In this episode

In the eighth episode of How to Think Like a Lawyer, Alexander is joined by Aneesa Noor, a second-year law student at Leeds Beckett University and a serving magistrate, for a look inside the magistrates’ court from the other side of the room: how a bench of three ordinary members of the public reaches fair decisions on guilt and sentencing.

Aneesa starts by busting the two biggest myths about the magistracy: that you need to be a qualified lawyer, and that you need to be retired. She explains how a friend’s suggestion led her to apply while studying for her LLB, and walks listeners through the full application process, from court observations and references to the six key attributes, the online assessment, the panel interview and appointment by the Senior Presiding Judge. In her case, the process took a full year.

She describes how she fits sittings around her degree, and what it was like walking into court for her first sitting: the nerves, the support of her mentor, and learning to share her views on the bench. She also talks about the range of cases she sits on, and why some are much harder to sit through than others.

The conversation then turns to deciding guilt. Aneesa explains what it really means for a bench to be sure, why the burden of proof always sits with the prosecution, and how a bench works through disagreement as a team. She shares how listening to her fellow magistrates once changed her mind. She also explains the line between the legal adviser’s role and the bench’s, why magistrates must give reasons for their decisions, and why nerves alone shouldn’t decide whether a witness is credible.

At the centre of the episode, Alexander puts Aneesa on the bench with a hypothetical case: a man who smashes a car window to rescue a dog on a hot afternoon. She walks through how a bench would approach the charge of criminal damage, the defence of lawful excuse, the difference between an honest belief and an objectively justified one, and how the bench would approach sentencing if he were convicted.

Alexander and Aneesa then explore sentencing more broadly: balancing consistency with treating each defendant as an individual, why a guilty plea earns a reduction, and how much weight the impact on a victim should carry. From the bench, Aneesa shares what makes an advocate persuasive and what costs them credibility, and how the court stays fair when a defendant has no lawyer.

The interview also looks at why members of the public should decide most criminal cases, whether AI could ever have a role in judicial decisions, and how her own non-traditional route into law shapes the way she sees the people who come before the bench. She speaks candidly about how heavy the responsibility can feel, and why being impartial doesn’t mean being emotionless.

Finally, Aneesa explains how deciding cases has changed the way she would argue them as a future barrister, and gives her advice to young people thinking about becoming a magistrate: step out of your comfort zone and don’t wait until you feel completely ready.

Topics covered include: the magistracy, magistrates’ courts, becoming a magistrate, the application process, criminal justice, the burden and standard of proof, deciding guilt, the legal adviser, giving reasons, witness credibility, criminal damage, lawful excuse, sentencing, sentencing guidelines, guilty pleas, victim impact, advocacy, unrepresented defendants, lay justice, AI in the justice system, access to law, non-traditional routes into law and careers at the Bar.

How to Think Like a Lawyer, Episode 08: The Role of a Magistrate with Aneesa Noor.

Key Takeaways

  • Aneesa Noor is a second-year law student at Leeds Beckett University and a serving magistrate.
  • Magistrates do not need to be qualified lawyers or retired, and Noor applied while studying for her LLB.
  • In Noor’s case, the application process took a full year and included court observations, references, an online assessment and a panel interview.
  • The episode discusses how magistrates assess guilt, give reasons for decisions and approach sentencing as a bench.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many people are on the magistrates’ bench described in the episode?

Three ordinary members of the public.

Who appoints magistrates, according to the episode?

The Senior Presiding Judge.

How long did Noor’s application process take?

A full year in her case.

What hypothetical case does the episode use to explore criminal damage?

A man smashing a car window to rescue a dog on a hot afternoon.