Live Feed:New episodes, highlights, and rapid recaps
Episodes
•38:05 •S2E9

What Happens When You Get Arrested? with Aaron Steel | How to Think Like a Lawyer

In this episode

In the ninth episode of How to Think Like a Lawyer, Alexander is joined by Aaron Steel, an accredited police station representative, author, actor and barrister, for a look inside the police station: what really happens from the moment someone is arrested to the moment they are charged, bailed or released.

Aaron starts by explaining what a police station representative does, why you don’t need a law degree to become one, and how reps cover the call-out at one o’clock in the morning while making sure the police follow PACE. He busts two big myths: that reps without a law degree give worse advice, and that the duty solicitor works for the police.

The conversation then follows a case step by step. Aaron explains what happens when someone is arrested and read their rights, including the right to free and independent legal advice, how the call reaches a solicitor and then a rep, why clients are warned not to talk about their case in the cell or on the bridge, and the forty-five minute guideline once the police are ready to interview. Inside the station he describes what disclosure is, how he uses the custody record, and how he takes a client’s account before advising them.

At the centre of the episode is the interview under caution. Aaron explains the three parts of the caution, why what you say in interview can make or break a case, and how he helps clients choose between a full account, a prepared statement and no comment, using a breach of a restraining order as an example. He also covers phone PINs, identification procedures and forensic samples.

Alexander and Aaron then look at the ethics of the role: what a rep should do when a client privately admits an offence but denies it in interview, why the duty to the court comes first, and how sections 76 and 78 of PACE deal with confessions and unfair evidence. Aaron also explains how he builds trust with frightened clients, his working relationship with officers and custody staff, and what changes when a suspect is under eighteen or vulnerable.

Next, they look at what happens after the interview: no further action, police cautions, community resolutions, bail and release under investigation, and how long the police can hold someone and when they must let them go. Aaron also tackles the biggest misconception about arrest, that being arrested does not mean you are guilty, and explains why having a solicitor with you never makes you look guilty.

The interview also covers the bigger picture: why free legal advice matters whatever your income, what Aaron learned at Citizens Advice, and the backlog in the criminal justice system. He also names the one law he’d change tomorrow, and it has nothing to do with the police station and everything to do with football.

Finally, Aaron talks about his route into the law: shadowing a solicitor for free, qualifying as a rep, saving for the Bar course, and being called to the Bar as an unregistered barrister while he looks for pupillage. He explains how acting shapes the way he advocates, what makes a good police station rep, how he copes with the tough days, and his advice to his younger self: don’t stress so much.

Topics covered include: police station representatives, arrest, police custody, the right to legal advice, the duty solicitor, PACE, the police caution, interview under caution, the right to silence, no comment interviews, prepared statements, disclosure, the custody record, appropriate adults, vulnerable suspects, confessions, unfair evidence, bail, release under investigation, out-of-court disposals, community resolutions, detention time limits, the criminal justice backlog, legal aid, access to justice, advocacy, acting and advocacy, becoming a barrister, pupillage and careers in criminal law.

How to Think Like a Lawyer — Episode 09: What Happens When You Get Arrested? with Aaron Steel.

Key Takeaways

  • Aaron Steel is an accredited police station representative, author, actor and barrister.
  • Police station representatives help ensure police follow PACE and can provide legal advice without having a law degree.
  • The episode follows the custody process from arrest and legal advice through interview and possible outcomes such as bail or release.
  • Aaron discusses how representatives help clients choose between giving a full account, making a prepared statement or answering “no comment” in interview.
  • The episode covers legal ethics, vulnerable suspects, detention time limits, access to free legal advice and Aaron’s route into the law.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a police station representative do?

A police station representative is an accredited adviser who goes to the police station to advise someone who has been arrested, mainly before and during their interview. They also make sure the police follow PACE, the law that sets out how suspects must be treated. In the episode, Aaron explains that you don’t need a law degree to become one.

What is the police caution?

Aaron explains it has three parts. You don’t have to say anything. It may harm your defence if you don’t mention something in interview that you later rely on in court. And anything you do say can be given in evidence, usually as a typed transcript of the recorded interview.

Should you go “no comment” in a police interview?

There’s no single rule, and Aaron says that “always go no comment” is a myth. The right choice depends on the client’s story, how they’d come across in interview and what evidence the police already have. The options are a full account, a prepared statement or no comment. The advice comes from the representative, but the decision is always the client’s.

Does the duty solicitor work for the police?

No. Aaron calls this one of the biggest myths in his field. The duty solicitor is an independent solicitor from a publicly available duty register, and solicitors take turns covering the slot. Legal advice at the police station is free whatever your income.

How long can the police hold you?

The starting point is 24 hours. Aaron explains that for serious offences the police can seek extensions, first from a senior officer and then, in the most serious cases, from a magistrates’ court. When the time runs out they must charge the person or release them.